Thursday, September 16, 2021

Season of the Witch: 20th Annual Event Raises Broomsticks and Charity Funds

Three years ago, when attending my daughter’s soccer game at Tidelands Park, I remember spying a woman dressed in Puritan clothing with blood splattered all over her apron and her hair neatly tucked away in a white bonnet.

Then, out of nowhere, streamed a group of women clad in flowing black smocks with shades of purple—all wearing pointy black hats.

- Advertisement -


Who says witches only wear black?

- Advertisement -

Mesmerized, I vowed that next year I would be part of the best-kept secret on the island—the Coronado Witches’ Tea. And so mote it be! I am now a two-year veteran witch.

Head Witch Rebecca Geiss with Karin Morris; Photo Courtesy of Karin Morris

As the folklore goes, Rebecca Geiss sent a cryptic invitation to eight of her closest friends asking them to dress as a witch and meet at the Old Town Trolley Station at 3 pm sharp on All Hallow’s Eve. What started as an intimate celebration of the holiday has become a Coronado tradition. Six of the nine original witches were in attendance this year. 

Now held annually on the Saturday before Halloween, this year’s event marked the 20th anniversary of the all-female (aged 21 and over) coven of witches boasting 250 broomriders.

Instead of invitations, this autumn affair travels by word of mouth and sold out before ticket sales went online–a testament to its reputation. While many attendees are local, witches as far as Washington DC, Connecticut, Oregon, Idaho, and Arizona flew in for the afternoon festivities.

Funds were raised for Team Quinn, a non-profit organization serving people with disabilities or disabling conditions and their families through adaptive surf programs, blood drive sponsorships, and purchasing monthly community meals for the Ronald McDonald House in San Diego. On November 2nd, Team Quinn will hold an Adaptive Surf and Assisted Yoga Session in Coronado.

Image Courtesy of Team Quinn social media

Inspired by Quinn Waitley, an identical quadruplet and adaptive athlete born with spastic Cerebral Palsy, Geiss discovered the organization through a friend while on a road trip. Touched by Waitley’s story, she decided to support Team Quinn for this year’s Witches’ Tea.

In 2018, Geiss partnered with the C4 Foundation that provides support and resources through science-based programs to active duty Navy SEALs and their families. She hopes to spread awareness and raise funds for different non-profits at future events.

Geiss singlehandedly planned this year’s agenda and donated transportation costs. But she “couldn’t have done it without the loving support of her husband and son who manage the behind the scenes logistics.” Since the event has grown in popularity, Geiss hopes to form a planning committee in 2020 to alleviate some of the toiling.

As any good witch knows, this event is more than just a bunch of women dressing in costumes. Geiss describes the Witches’ Tea as a “generational tradition” with mothers bringing their now-grown daughters to revel in the day.

It’s also liberating to be in the presence of so many women of all ages and backgrounds in the spirit of celebration. The atmosphere is simply electrifying.

And much like the Kentucky Derby–it’s all about the creative and crafty headpieces.


Shroud in secrecy, witches are only told where to meet and to bring a broom. A flash mob practice video was sent weeks prior with choreographer, Sue-Allen Villalva, donating her time to teach the spellbinding moves before the big reveal last Saturday.

Choregrapher Sue-Allen Villalva leading the dance

This year’s agenda began at the Coronado Ferry Landing with hundreds of witches dancing to “Jump in the Line (Shake Señora).” Afterward, we hopped on our broomsticks (four double-decker buses owned by the British Bus Company) and flew over the bridge to The Shout House. Women were singing and dancing to “The Time Warp” and other tunes, while Geiss was serenaded with an original birthday song by one of the dueling piano players.

“Virgin” witch (a term used for a newbie) and longtime Coronado resident, Liz Bruhin, spoke on her excitement about joining the coven ranks and engaging in some boisterous behavior that is “rumored to occur” on these little jaunts.

“I hear crazy things happen at these events.”

The next stop took us to Bali Hai on Shelter Island and witches were warned “not to drink the Mai Tais,” known for their intoxicating ingredients. At the bayside restaurant, “tea time” consisted of tomato basil soup, mandarin salad with beet dressing, and chicken sandwiches.

Local Coven and Long time Attendees: Connie Spitzer, Kate Carinder, Lori Blumenthal, Karen Lafferty, Chris Keyes, Kathy Couture; Image Courtesy of Rebecca Geiss

We returned to Coronado where witches reunited with family members at the Mexican Village and danced the waning afternoon hours away to music provided by IT’S NEVER 2L8 band who volunteered their time for the event. Geiss described how accommodating the Mexican Village management was due to a last minute change in the agenda. 

“They removed tables to open up the dance floor for us and rearranged the bar area to allow for more witches to roam. They were very generous and helpful.”

Gretchen Barksdale, a returning witch, described the women-only event as a moment “to be free from the societal expectations of being wife, mother, proper, ladylike, and whatever else a ‘good woman’ is supposed to be, and be wildly woman. Even if it’s for one afternoon, it’s worth the yearly wait.”

Our Coven; Image Courtesy of Karin Morris



Be civil. Comments will be removed if they violate our T&C. Comments closed after 14 days.

Andrea Kade
Coastal waters have always been home to Andrea, who grew up in Texas and resided in beach communities along the Gulf of Mexico, Atlantic, and Pacific. Always the explorer, Andrea enjoys California camping and stumbling across small towns in her travels with her spouse and three children who attend Village Elementary. Sometimes you can glimpse her admiring the architecture and distinctive plant life that makes Coronado extraordinary.She received her BA in English from Old Dominion University and her MA in English from San Diego State University where she taught for two years. In those rare moments of solitude, Andrea indulges in southern novels, far too much coffee, and biking off the beaten path. Have a story for The Coronado Times to cover? Send news tips or story ideas to:
Sponsored Partner Links