Monday, July 6, 2020

SANDAG Presents A Flawed Regional Housing Needs Assessment Draft Methodology For Public Comment

Letters to the Editor submitted to The Coronado Times are the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the publisher, editors or writers of this publication. Submit letters to

Submitted by Mary Scyocurka

The SANDAG Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) Subcommittee Board Members have been presented a flawed methodology by SANDAG staff. The methodology used to calculate each city’s allocation of new housing units does not take into account particular issues that each of the cities will face.

For instance, coastal cities are already dense areas with higher costs of living, which tenants of subsidized housing will find difficult to afford. There are also environmental issues that would need to be addressed by the Coastal Commission before development can be increased along the shoreline. But because coastal cities have the trains running through them, they are being hit by high numbers.

- Advertisement -

There are areas, such as Imperial Beach and Coronado, that already have high density. Coronado has approximately 12,000 citizens per square mile, one of the densest areas of the county. There is essentially no land available for development.

Inland areas, especially the Unincorporated Areas, have the land to build plenty of the desired housing; however, there is literally no public transportation.

The methodology shows no regard for market forces. An Escondido council person stated that their city has streamlined the permit process. However, the city has been unable to find developers willing to build there.

- Advertisement -

Sacramento requested 171,000 new housing units for San Diego County. SANDAG had the opportunity to respond to the State with a lower figure. Upon discussion, the SANDAG Board came up with a more realistic figure that would commit the County to 60,000 fewer new homes. Some SANDAG members, however, voted for the higher number. Solana Beach is one city that voted for more housing, yet Solana Beach is being allotted the second lowest allocation.

The methodology does not take into account current density. State law requires SANDAG to consider constraints to development, such as sufficient infrastructure and availability of suitable land. It also does not take into account that cities with low populations may receive special consideration. Tribes on Indian Reservations have also not been taken into regard.

- Advertisement -

SANDAG’s Executive Director, Hassan Ikhrata stated that the methodology which would be presented to the Board would not necessarily make sense, but would be something that would be acceptable to Sacramento.

The RHNA Draft Methodology, which was presented to the entire Board, took into consideration on-base military housing. It is logical that cities should not be required to ensure homes for service members, who already have housing. SANDAG Board Members, who voted against the Subcommittee’s recommendations, have put out for Public Comment the Draft Methodology, which does not count military housing, but counts military jobs.

The jurisdictions only met 45% of their current cycle obligations. The proposed numbers are unachievable. While it is unlikely that even half of these homes will be built, certain SANDAG Board Members seem determined to put something on paper to appease Sacramento.

It is going to be impossible for cities to meet the submitted allocations. This will result in Sacramento withholding funds from and/or filing lawsuits against individual jurisdictions. This will penalize the citizens, from whom the funds have come, through their taxes.

For Coronado, this means that if the city does not build its obligation of 1,001 new housing units between 2019 and 2029, Sacramento will withhold $440,000 and Coronado will likely be hit with legal problems.

SANDAG has opened the Regional Housing Needs Assessment Draft Methodology for Public Comment through August 9th. Voters can send an email to all SANDAG Board Members through their clerk at

  Mary Scyocurka


Do You Value The Coronado Times?
Become a Paid Supporter

Keep it civil. Comments may be removed or closed if they violate Terms of Service.

Managing Editor
Originally from upstate New York, Dani Schwartz has lived in Coronado since 1996. She is thrilled to call Coronado home and raise her two children here. In her free time enjoys hitting the gym, reading, and walking her dog around the “island.”Have news to share? Send tips, story ideas or letters to the editor to:


4th of July Heritage

Submitted by Ch, Col (ret) Gary J. ZiccardiI am a Coronado resident since 2016 who served as Navy Surface Warfare Officer for 4 years,...

Chief Kaye’s Compassion and Kind Actions Stand Out

Submitted by Carolyn RogersonWe never know when a dire emergency will strike our lives. When such a crisis confronted Coronado visitors Mike and Jan...

Congratulations Coronado High School Class of 2020

Submitted by Gene Thomas GomulkaOne should not be surprised that the San Diego County Health Department issued a cease and desist order in regard...

Acting on Our Principles

Submitted by Jim DeBelloWhile the soaring SpaceX launch this weekend lifted our spirits and re-ignited our faith to achieve greatness, we are brought back...


Video: Navy Leap Frogs Parachute into Coronado

The Coronado Fourth of July Parade Committee and the Navy Leap Frogs brought some Independence Day thrills to Glorietta Bay with these "on-the-spot" landings...

Marvin Heinze Encourages Us to “Mask Up Coronado”

Coronado City Council member Marvin Heinze speaks about the very contagious coronavirus and how covering our face is one way we can help protect...

Undercover Philanthropist Donna Salof Awarded Key to the City at Feast and Fareway

It’s not every day that you’re given a key to the city by the Mayor of Coronado. Just ask Donna Salof, who turned 70...

Sandcastle Man Shares a Message in His Art

The famous Sandcastle Man of Coronado Beach is using his art to ask people to wear masks, socially distance, and be aware that we...

Nicky Rottens Reopening: New Look, Even Better Burgers

Nicky Rottens has become a staple in the Coronado community for the past nine years. From obtaining a license that allows for all ages...