Saturday, March 28, 2020

Stories of Survival and Solidarity: Former POW/MIA Wives Share Experiences

At a Meet & Greet on October 5, Ellen Miller, spouse of Vice Adm. Dewolfe "Chip" Miller, hosted "The League of Wives" author, Heath Hardage Lee, along with four Navy family panelists: Sid Stockdale, Patsy Crayton, Karen Butler, and Marie Estocin, for a discussion and Q&A with an audience of Naval spouses and local women.

“The war we didn’t talk about.”

That’s how Ellen Miller described the way the Vietnam War wasn’t covered in most history classes. In her welcome address at a Meet & Greet on October 5th, Miller, spouse of Vice Adm. Dewolfe “Chip” Miller, expressed heartfelt admiration for the former Prisoner of War/Missing in Action (POW/MIA) wives and family members present.

One attendee, Tori Calisch, an active duty Naval Aviator spouse, declared it a deeply moving experience. “These women are truly American heroes. I am in awe of the courageous actions they took to bring their husbands home and the legacy these women left for military families going forward.”


Sponsored by Lincoln Military Housing and the Naval Officers’ Spouses’ Club of San Diego, the event featured The League of Wives author, Heath Hardage Lee, and four Navy family panelists (Sid Stockdale, Patsy Crayton, Karen Butler, and Marie Estocin) whose poignant stories fill the pages of Lee’s book. While most accounts of the controversial Vietnam War focus on the grim experience of those veterans, The League of Wives chronicles the efforts of POW/MIA wives and their public campaign to bring their husbands home.


But not all would make it back.

Lee, who built a rapport with the POW/MIA families, moderated the panel discussion and provided context for the political climate and her book’s findings. She explained how these military wives empowered themselves to “Go Public” with the harsh and inhuman treatment of POWs and lack of information provided to MIA families.

And it all began at a dining room table in Coronado with the formation of The League of Wives.

Heath Hardage Lee and Ellen Miller
Author Heath Hardage Lee and Ellen Miller looking at a 1960s Naval Aviator spouse scrapbook.

“I wanted to set the record straight. Sybil Stockdale is the one who started this movement.” Lee said, referring to the murky beginnings of what would eventually morph into a larger national organization, The National League of POW/MIA Families.

Sid Stockdale, Sybil and Vice Adm. James Stockdale’s son, recalls the moment their family discovered his dad had been shot down. “It was a very emotional time because we were told he was missing in action.” Unsure if she was a wife or widow, Sybil received a letter from her husband seven months later. He was alive, but would remain a POW for seven years.

Meet & Greet Signing

Another panelist and Sybil’s close friend, Karen Butler, discovered her Naval Aviator husband, Lt. Phillip Butler, was alive—five weeks after he was shot down. She found out while watching the TODAY show on television.

Look Magazine Dec 1970
LOOK magazine featuring POW wives

Playing an instrumental role in getting LOOK magazine to cover the POW/MIA wives, Butler says she never felt the pressure of the “Keep Quiet” policy that Lee describes in her book.

Another Naval Aviator spouse, Patsy Crayton, had a premonition on the day Lt. Cmdr. Render Crayton was shot down. She learned of his survival after someone identified him at POW camp. It would be five years before she received a letter from him through Cora Weiss, a controversial “peace” activist.

Crayton became a close confidant to Sybil Stockdale. The two women frequented the Hotel Del Coronado pool with Stockdale’s four boys. Crayton laughed when describing one incident where Stockdale disciplined two of her boys bickering, “it’s not fair!” at each other. Stockdale admonished, “Life’s not fair! And the sooner you find that out, the better off you are!” This moment earned a rousing applause from pool guests.

Reunion: Former POW/MIA Navy wives

Of all the emotional and occasionally humorous stories told on Saturday afternoon, none could quite compare to Marie Estocin’s heart-rending experience. Lt. Cmdr. Michael Estocin was shot down on April 26, 1967. Devastated and shocked, Estocin was told not to “hold out hope” for her MIA husband.

But she did.

Estocin would attend the Paris peace talks hoping for more information regarding her husband’s status. But the North Vietnamese delegation literally slammed the door in their faces.

Unlike the Stockdale family, who were not allowed to watch the “violent” news images, Estocin scoured them hoping to glimpse her husband’s face among the POWs. When she wrote a letter to Weiss in a bid to determine if her husband was among the list of POWs, the reply stated: prisoner not detained.

To this day, Lieutenant Commander Michael J. Estocin is still listed as Missing in Action.

Ellen Miller and Pat Mearns
Cover Girl: Pat Mearns with Ellen Miller

Pat Mearns, a “cover girl” on The League of Wives book, was also sitting in the audience. An Air Force wife, her husband, Maj. Arthur Mearns, was also listed as missing in action. Later, it would be reported that he was killed in the crash. However, Mearns continued to be a driving force behind the MIA side of the movement with Sybil Stockdale.

At the conclusion of the panel discussion, the floor opened for a Q&A session to an audience filled with Naval spouses and local women.

One woman, a former Glorietta High classmate of the Stockdale boys, described how she wore their father’s name on her POW bracelet. Millions of these bracelets were manufactured and thousands returned when men, or their remains, were repatriated. Families revealed they are still being mailed, as one attendee acknowledged receiving a bracelet last week.

POW/MIA Bracelets. Image: Smithsonian Institute National Museum of American History

When asked about the process of repatriation, the former POW wives described the horrific physical conditions of their husbands. Crayton explained how her 6’ 2” husband weighed 140 pounds upon his return. Despite his emaciated frame, he had a large, hard lump stretching across his stomach. After a round of chemotherapy, he passed the parasitic worms he acquired while imprisoned in Vietnam.

Astoundingly, only two percent of the “Hanoi Hilton” prisoners were diagnosed with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder.

The “tap system” and SERE (Survival, Evasion, Resistance, and Escape) training were considered to be the largest factor behind the low numbers. As for the POW/MIA children, daughters faired better, mentally and emotionally, than the sons. Sid Stockdale believes the absent father figure affected them more.

After the Q&A session, the author and four panelists signed books and spoke with attendees. The Naval Officers’ Spouse Club provided copies of The League of Wives, in addition to refreshments and snacks.

“I am ever so grateful for their bold strength in the face of life-shattering tragedy,” said Amy Miller, another Naval Aviator spouse (no relation to Ellen or Vice Adm. Miller). Describing the afternoon as “truly priceless,” Miller felt the experience exhibited the kinship felt across generations of Naval Aviator wives.


Learn more about “The League of Wives” exhibition currently on display at the Coronado Historical Association here.

Learn more about The League of Wives author, Heath Hardage Lee in her interview here.


Breaking Coronado News >> SUBSCRIBE

Andrea Kade
Andrea Kade
Coastal waters have always been home to Andrea, who grew up in Texas and resided in beach communities along the Gulf of Mexico, Atlantic, and Pacific. Always the explorer, Andrea enjoys California camping and stumbling across small towns in her travels with her spouse and three children who attend Village Elementary. Sometimes you can glimpse her admiring the architecture and distinctive plant life that makes Coronado extraordinary.She received her BA in English from Old Dominion University and her MA in English from San Diego State University where she taught for two years. In those rare moments of solitude, Andrea indulges in southern novels, far too much coffee, and biking off the beaten path. Have a story for The Coronado Times to cover? Send news tips or story ideas to:


Good News in the Virus Front

Submitted by Daron A. Case, Esq. With the COVID-19 pandemic and related statewide lockdown in place, economies are getting hammered on a national, state and...

Support All Local Coronado Businesses

Written by Steve AlbertWe have been doing an AMAZING job supporting our local restaurants, so let's keep that energy going for our local retail...

Free Summer Shuttle Service for Cays?

Submitted by Daron A. Case, Esq.Honorable Mayor & Council,Please remove item 5c (free summer shuttle program) from the consent calendar for this afternoon's City...

Take Mexico to The Hague for Violation of International Treaty

Submitted by Baron Von Partlow, Leon Benham, Lance Rodgers, Daron A. Case, Esq.February 28, 2020President Donald J. Trump The White House 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. Washington, DC 20500Subject: Take Mexico to...


First Coronado COVID-19 Case Confirmed by County of San Diego

The County of San Diego has reported the first case of Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in Coronado. The county updates daily its list of cases...

New Chicano Park Mural Focuses on Immigration

Chicano Park, the vibrantly painted park under the Coronado Bridge, is adding a new mural to its impressive visual collection. The project, headed by...

San Diego Man in 20s Dies from Coronavirus – Brings County Total to Six

Three more San Diegans have died from complications of COVID-19, bringing the region’s total to six, the County Health and Human Services Agency announced...

Local Heroes: People Helping People During the Coronavirus Crisis

I’ve always loved this quote from Mr. Rogers. “When I was a boy and I would see scary things in the news, my mother...

Coronado’s Talent Winner – 11 Year Old Bobby Latona (Video)

We invite you to take just three minutes... turn off the tv, gather your family, and experience an 11 year old Coronado boy giving...