Friday, July 3, 2020

Curbing Mobile Use: How CUSD Handles Smart Devices

Coronado High School “Islanders” returned to the academic year with a new policy instituted: No More Cell Phones in Backpacks. Now students must place their phones in numbered slots on a wall-mounted organizer when they enter the classroom. The intended effect is to maximize educational learning by decreasing smart device distractions.

So what initiated this “small change?”

- Advertisement -

For starters, the old policy allowed for each teacher to define their classroom’s “cell phone use” guidelines. Unfortunately, this generated a power struggle between teacher and student due to differing approaches.

CHS also participated in Screen Free Week last year, where teachers engaged in critical conversations discussing screen time with students and reported significant improvements in learning.

CHS Wall Organizer for Cell Phones

- Advertisement -

Principal Shane Schmeichel acknowledges the “draw to the device is strong” and says “students know there is a problem when it comes to their cell phone use.” When he first presented this new concept to the PTO, opinions were across the board. But, since its inception, CHS has received only praise from parents or staffers.

CHS believes the school environment is “ultimately about the culture of learning” and that should encompass scholastic instruction with social and emotional learning.

- Advertisement -

And the results so far–astounding.

One CHS English teacher, Jean Pehrsson, declares the policy is having a “wonderful effect on the classroom environment. Students are more focused and engaged.”

But, policies on smart devices aren’t limited to the “Islander” campus.

The Coronado Unified School District seems to be taking a page from Cal Newport’s theories on “digital minimalism” and “deep work.”  Like Newport’s idea on removing distractions to improve focus on thinking tasks, CUSD also instills limitations to address technology distractions.

Village and Silver Strand Elementary Schools require students to keep mobile and tablet devices in their backpacks while on campus. However, the trend of younger students owning smartwatches over smartphones, continues to be a developing concern for school officials, says VES Assistant Principal Tanya White.

Today’s parents seem to prefer smartwatches for grade-schoolers because they provide the basics of communication—talk/text functions without internet access and social media triggering parental anxiety.

Image from Garmin website

Jenny Moore, Principal at Silver Strand, observes students as young as kindergarten wearing smartwatches. She points out that while parents mainly use them for communication, they may also be tracking their children.

“They are, however, a distraction,” Moore admits, “and we’ve had students call parents from class/campus, creating concerns for school and family. We are asking that children remove them upon arrival and put them back on when they dismiss.”

Moore states, “[they] will be reminding parents of this expectation throughout the year.”

Technology isn’t completely barred from Silver Strand classrooms. The school implements Hapara, a program with safety measures designed to maximize learning time. Teachers use this tool to assign a page or project while monitoring student screen use and navigation.

Although CUSD elementary schools view smartwatches and phones as a continued distraction, they acknowledge there isn’t much concern for this age group regarding issues like cyberbullying. However, on a campus filled with texting ‘tweens, Coronado Middle School places these topics at its forefront.

CMS Assistant Principal, Brooke Falar, helps spearhead the initiative to teach middle schoolers how to be responsible smart device users. Holding a campus-wide assembly at the beginning of the year, CMS discusses cell phone use and cyberbullying with students. It also addresses them in daily broadcasts and in-class conversations.

Photo by Brad Pouncey on Unsplash

While some CMS students need reminders about its “no cell phone” policy, Falar’s next comment echoes Silver Strand’s problem, “it can be challenging when parents text their children during school hours.”

However, the Bring Your Own Device program, “personalized education for every child…to help each unique student learning need,” seems to conflict with the campus-wide “no cell phone policy.” The CMS 2019-2020 Handbook states that acceptable devices range from laptops, netbooks, Chromebooks, iPads, to smartphones and other pertinent technology.

Falar asserts that “device” usually refers to laptops or tablets. She clarifies, “we want to give teachers the flexibility to let students use a phone in class if they deem it appropriate, however, this is not usually the case.”

Although there are differing policies for age groups, CUSD is making strides on its campuses and continues to explore and challenge how students, staffers, and parents approach smart devices.


Do You Value The Coronado Times?
Become a Paid Supporter

Keep it civil. Comments may be removed or closed if they violate Terms of Service.

Andrea Kade
Andrea Kade
Coastal waters have always been home to Andrea, who grew up in Texas and resided in beach communities along the Gulf of Mexico, Atlantic, and Pacific. Always the explorer, Andrea enjoys California camping and stumbling across small towns in her travels with her spouse and three children who attend Village Elementary. Sometimes you can glimpse her admiring the architecture and distinctive plant life that makes Coronado extraordinary.She received her BA in English from Old Dominion University and her MA in English from San Diego State University where she taught for two years. In those rare moments of solitude, Andrea indulges in southern novels, far too much coffee, and biking off the beaten path. Have a story for The Coronado Times to cover? Send news tips or story ideas to:


Chief Kaye’s Compassion and Kind Actions Stand Out

Submitted by Carolyn RogersonWe never know when a dire emergency will strike our lives. When such a crisis confronted Coronado visitors Mike and Jan...

Congratulations Coronado High School Class of 2020

Submitted by Gene Thomas GomulkaOne should not be surprised that the San Diego County Health Department issued a cease and desist order in regard...

Acting on Our Principles

Submitted by Jim DeBelloWhile the soaring SpaceX launch this weekend lifted our spirits and re-ignited our faith to achieve greatness, we are brought back...

I See Your Colors

Submitted by Rebekah KobsAs the world is aching right now I know each family is trying to process things in their own way. For...


Marvin Heinze Encourages Us to “Mask Up Coronado”

Coronado City Council member Marvin Heinze speaks about the very contagious coronavirus and how covering our face is one way we can help protect...

Undercover Philanthropist Donna Salof Awarded Key to the City at Feast and Fareway

It’s not every day that you’re given a key to the city by the Mayor of Coronado. Just ask Donna Salof, who turned 70...

Sandcastle Man Shares a Message in His Art

The famous Sandcastle Man of Coronado Beach is using his art to ask people to wear masks, socially distance, and be aware that we...

Nicky Rottens Reopening: New Look, Even Better Burgers

Nicky Rottens has become a staple in the Coronado community for the past nine years. From obtaining a license that allows for all ages...

Silver Strand State Beach Parking Lots to be Closed July 3-5

The City of Coronado confirmed that parking lots at Silver Strand State Beach will be closed from July 3-5.  The Silver Strand State Beach...