Thursday, August 11, 2022

CIF Strips Coronado of Basketball Championship, Levies Multiple Sanctions

CIF State Executive Director Concludes Investigation of Incident that Occurred After Conclusion of Southern California Boys Basketball Division 4-A Regional Championship

SACRAMENTO — After a thorough review and analysis of the incident following the conclusion of the Division 4-A Regional Basketball Championship game between Coronado High School and Orange Glen High School, the CIF State Executive Director reiterates that discriminatory and racially insensitive behaviors toward an opponent contravene the principles of education-based athletics. In this instance, there is no doubt the act of throwing tortillas at a predominately Latino team is unacceptable and warrants sanctions.

While consequences are warranted for such an egregious action as throwing tortillas at a predominantly Latino team and the sanctions below are being levied on the athletic program at Coronado High School, we must all be aware that behavior does not normally change with sanctions alone. The path towards real change comes with the development of empathy for those who are on the receiving end of this type of degrading and demeaning behavior, no matter the proffered intent of that behavior. Adherence to the principles of Pursuing Victory with Honor is expected at all levels of high school athletic events and, in particular, championship contests.

Based on the investigations conducted by the local schools and school districts, the events depicted in the video evidence, and this office’s review, the sanctions below are levied against Coronado High School:

  1. The 2021 Southern California Boys Basketball Division 4-A Regional Championship is vacated.
  2. Coronado High School is on probation for the 2021-2022, 2022-2023, and 2023-2024 school years.
  3. The Coronado High School boys basketball team will not host postseason contests at the Section, Regional, or State levels for the 2021-2022 and 2022-2023 school years.
  4. All other teams in the Coronado High School athletic program will not host postseason contests at the Section, Regional, or State levels until numbers 5 and 6 below have been completed.
  5. Completion of a sportsmanship workshop (to include a component of racial/cultural sensitivity training such as the NFHS Implicit Bias Course) for all Coronado High School administrators, athletic director(s), coaches, and student-athletes.
  6. Completion of game management training for all Coronado High School administrators and athletic director(s).
  7. The administration at Coronado High School is strongly encouraged to engage with the administration at Orange Glen High School to begin the process of developing a positive relationship between the two school communities. 

    Examples may include the following:
    a.) The administrators at the two schools work cooperatively to provide the student-athletes at both schools with a restorative justice opportunity.
    b.) The administrators at the two schools work with a community-based non-profit organization to conduct community service projects with their student-athletes and coaches.

Note: The details and reporting requirements of the above sanctions will be done in cooperation with Coronado High School, the State CIF, and the CIF-San Diego Section.

After the ruling by CIF, Coronado Unified School District send out the following release:

The California Interscholastic Federation (CIF) issued its decision today regarding the recent Division Championship game, where a post-game incident involved tossing tortillas into the crowd and at players. The CIF decided to levy various sanctions against Coronado High School, including vacating the 2021 Southern California Boys Basketball Division 4-A Regional Championship. We are currently reviewing the decision and will evaluate a possible appeal. We have also retained an outside investigator to thoroughly review the incident, which will guide any additional corrective actions. Whatever actions we take to address this matter, this incident and the CIF decision have served as clear reminders of the importance of sportsmanship and respectful conduct toward one another.

– Karl Mueller, CUSD Superintendent


Islanders Win CIF Div. 4-A Regional Title Ahead of Controversial Postgame Altercation

Tortilla-Throwing Overshadows Coronado High School Basketball Championship Win, CIF Investigates

Coronado Resident Admits to Buying and Distributing Tortillas – Answers Questions

Coronado Times
Coronado Times
Have news to share? Send tips, story ideas or letters to the editor to: [email protected]